The TCL 50 XL NxtPaper is an innovative smartphone designed with a unique display technology that emphasizes eye comfort and an improved viewing experience. The device boasts a 6.75-inch NxtPaper display, a feature TCL has developed to mimic the look of paper, which is claimed to be more gentle on the eyes compared to traditional screens. It’s a budget-friendly phone with a mid-range performance, catering to users who prioritize screen quality and multimedia consumption.
However, despite its impressive display and attractive price point, the TCL 50 XL NxtPaper has garnered mixed reviews, with some users reporting a range of issues and bugs that affect their overall experience. In this detailed analysis, we will delve deep into the common problems and limitations that users have encountered, assess the impact of these issues on everyday use, and explore whether the TCL 50 XL NxtPaper is a good choice compared to other similarly-priced smartphones in the market.
1. Display: Revolutionary Concept with Some Drawbacks
The NxtPaper display is the star feature of the TCL 50 XL. It is designed to reduce eye strain by mimicking the look of paper, especially in bright light. While this technology is promising, there are some important issues to consider.
a) Low Brightness in Direct Sunlight
- Problem: One of the most common complaints with the NxtPaper display is that it struggles to reach high brightness levels, particularly in direct sunlight.
- Cause: The technology behind NxtPaper may be more power-efficient, but it sacrifices brightness for the sake of a paper-like experience.
- Impact: This limits the visibility of the screen in bright outdoor environments, which can be frustrating for users who spend a lot of time outside.
- User Experience:
“The screen looks fantastic indoors, but once I step into the sun, it’s almost impossible to see anything. I wish it was brighter, especially when I’m outside.” – User review on a tech forum.
b) Color Accuracy Issues
- Problem: Despite its impressive paper-like display, the NxtPaper screen is sometimes criticized for inaccurate color reproduction. Colors appear dull or washed out compared to other smartphones with OLED or LCD displays.
- Impact: This can be particularly noticeable when watching movies or viewing photos, where vivid colors are crucial to the experience.
- User Experience:
“The screen looks nice for reading, but when I watch videos, the colors look way too faded. It’s a real letdown for media consumption.” – Comment from a user on Reddit.
c) Limited Refresh Rate
- Problem: The TCL 50 XL NxtPaper features a 60Hz refresh rate, which is standard but feels a bit sluggish compared to other devices in the same price range that offer 90Hz or 120Hz displays.
- Impact: This lower refresh rate can make scrolling, gaming, and general use feel less smooth and fluid, especially if you’re accustomed to higher refresh rates.
- User Experience:
“The display looks good, but the 60Hz refresh rate is a bit of a letdown. Scrolling feels jerky, and it’s not as responsive as I’d hoped.” – Review from an Amazon customer.
2. Performance: Adequate but Not Exceptional
The TCL 50 XL NxtPaper is equipped with a MediaTek Helio G85 processor, paired with 4GB of RAM. While this combination is sufficient for day-to-day tasks, it doesn’t offer the same level of performance as some of its competitors in the same price range.
a) Lag and Slowdowns During Multitasking
- Problem: Users have reported occasional lag and slowdowns when switching between multiple apps or performing more intensive tasks.
- Cause: The Helio G85 is a budget processor, and while it’s good for light use, it can struggle when handling more demanding tasks or multiple apps running simultaneously.
- Impact: This can make the phone feel less responsive, especially when users try to perform tasks such as gaming, multitasking, or running apps that require more processing power.
- User Experience:
“The phone works fine for basic tasks, but when I try to switch between apps or play games, it lags a lot. It’s frustrating to use.” – User review on GSMArena.
b) Gaming Performance Limitations
- Problem: The TCL 50 XL NxtPaper’s gaming performance is limited due to the Helio G85 processor. While it can handle light games, it struggles with graphically intensive titles.
- Impact: Users who enjoy mobile gaming might find the experience less than ideal, with games like PUBG Mobile or Call of Duty Mobile running at lower settings and frame rates.
- User Experience:
“I can play simpler games, but anything more demanding lags terribly. I wouldn't recommend it for gaming enthusiasts.” – Feedback from a customer on a tech forum.
3. Battery Life: Long-Lasting, but Not Without Issues
The 5000mAh battery in the TCL 50 XL NxtPaper is one of its highlights, with the device generally offering decent battery life for typical users. However, some users have found that battery performance is inconsistent.
a) Rapid Battery Drain During Media Consumption
- Problem: A significant issue reported by users is rapid battery drain when watching videos or using apps that rely heavily on the display.
- Cause: The NxtPaper display, while power-efficient, still consumes more battery during media consumption, especially when the brightness is increased.
- Impact: This leads to a noticeable reduction in battery life, making users require a charge earlier than expected.
- User Experience:
“The battery drains too quickly when I watch videos or use the camera. I expected better performance considering the large battery.” – Comment from a user on a review site.
b) Slow Charging Speed
- Problem: Users have reported that the charging speed is relatively slow, taking a few hours to fully charge the phone from 0% to 100%.
- Impact: In comparison to other budget smartphones with faster charging speeds, this can be an inconvenience for users who need a quick charge.
- User Experience:
“It takes too long to charge up fully. I would have liked to see at least 18W fast charging for a phone of this size.” – Feedback on Amazon.
4. Camera Quality: Mediocre Performance
The TCL 50 XL NxtPaper is equipped with a 50MP primary camera and a 5MP secondary camera, which offer decent specifications on paper. However, in real-world usage, the camera experience doesn’t quite live up to expectations.
a) Poor Low-Light Performance
- Problem: The camera struggles in low-light conditions, with photos often appearing blurry or noisy.
- Impact: This can lead to disappointing photos in situations like indoor shots or at night, which are common use cases for smartphones today.
- User Experience:
“I’ve tried taking pictures at night, and the results are always blurry and grainy. The camera just can’t handle low-light conditions well.” – User review on GSMArena.
b) Lack of Optical Image Stabilization (OIS)
- Problem: The absence of OIS in the camera setup leads to noticeable shakes or blurred images in videos or photos taken with slight movement.
- Impact: This limits the overall quality of photos and videos, especially for those who want smoother shots during action sequences or video recording.
- User Experience:
“Video quality is shaky, and the photos often come out blurry if I move just a little. I would have expected better stabilization for this price.” – Review from a customer on Amazon.
5. Software and Updates: A Mixed Experience
The TCL 50 XL NxtPaper runs on Android 11 with TCL’s custom user interface. While the software experience is generally smooth, there are some issues worth noting.
a) Slow Software Updates
- Problem: Users have reported that the device receives slow or infrequent updates, meaning that new features and security patches can take a long time to arrive.
- Impact: This could pose a security risk, as outdated software may not have the latest security fixes.
- User Experience:
“I’m still waiting for Android 12, and it’s been months. Slow updates make me question the long-term support of this phone.” – Feedback from a user on a tech forum.
b) Bloatware and Pre-Installed Apps
- Problem: The device comes with a significant amount of bloatware and pre-installed apps, many of which cannot be uninstalled.
- Impact: This clutters the phone’s interface and consumes valuable storage space.
- User Experience:
“The phone is packed with unnecessary apps that I don’t need and can’t remove. It’s frustrating when you’re trying to make the most of limited storage.” – Comment from a customer on a review site.
Conclusion: Is the TCL 50 XL NxtPaper Worth Buying?
The TCL 50 XL NxtPaper offers a unique display technology that aims to reduce eye strain, and its affordable price point makes it an attractive option for users looking for a budget-friendly device. However, several performance and camera issues, coupled with slow charging and battery drain problems, may hinder its appeal for some users.
Pros:
- Innovative NxtPaper display for eye comfort.
- Large battery for extended usage.
- Affordable price with decent performance for basic tasks.
Cons:
- Low brightness in direct sunlight.
- Color accuracy issues and lower refresh rate.
- Slow performance during multitasking and gaming.
- Mediocre camera quality, especially in low light.
- Slow charging and battery drain during media consumption.
Better Alternatives:
- Xiaomi Redmi Note 11: Offers better performance, battery life, and camera quality at a similar price.
- Realme Narzo 50A: A strong competitor with better performance and battery efficiency.
- Samsung Galaxy A12: A solid mid-range option with a better display and performance.
Verdict: The TCL 50 XL NxtPaper is a solid option if you’re seeking a unique display experience and don’t mind sacrificing some performance and camera quality. However, for those seeking better performance, camera capabilities, and overall reliability, alternatives like the Xiaomi Redmi Note 11 or Realme Narzo 50A may be a better fit.